subscribe to receive my posts, special offers, recipes, and workouts.
≡ Menu

Did you know that it’s National Peanut Butter Lover’s Day? This is a day I’ve been celebrating since back in 2012!

I thought it would be fun to do a round up of some of my favorite things peanut butter related.

3 FAVORITE PLAIN PEANUT BUTTERS 

When it comes to plain old peanut butter, I’m a simple girl. I’m looking for two ingredients: peanuts and salt. Unsalted peanut butter is a no go for me. I love that slightly salty taste to balance out the sweet roasted peanuts. As far as texture goes, it must be spreadable and the runnier the better!

My Favorite Peanut Butters

1) Trader Joe’s Salted Crunchy and Creamy Natural Peanut Butter – the saltiest of them all and also the runniest/drippiest.

2) Whole Foods 365 Crunchy and Creamy Natural Peanut Butter – I love the bigger bulk size that you can get these jars in. They are easy to stir and taste great.

3) Smucker’s All Natural Peanut Butter – this may catch you buy surprise but this is my go-to when I’m traveling and have no access to Trader Joe’s, Whole Foods or a store with “fancy” nut butters. It’s got my two key ingredients, peanuts and salt, and a nice thick but still spreadable texture.

3 FAVORITE FLAVORED PEANUT BUTTERS

I will pick regular peanut butter over flavored any day of the week but I do mix it up on occasion. When I do, here are some of my favorites.

Three Favorite Flavored Peanut Butters

1) Wild Friends Peanut Butter – if I had to choose just one, I’d have to go with their seasonal Pumpkin Spice but I love them all so much! Especially the Honey Pretzel, Cinnamon Raisin and Chocolate Coconut.

2) Nut Butter Nation Honey Vanilla – I first discovered this peanut butter when the brand sent me samples and after tasting the Honey Vanilla I basically told my fiance, “hands off! It’s mine!” Their Brown Sugar Cinnamon also deserves a mention and also to be noted is that they meet my texture criteria.

3) Peanut Butter & Co. White Chocolate Wonderful – while I do love Dark Chocolate Dreams, White Chocolate Wonderful really has my heart. It’s my favorite thicker texture peanut butter.

3 FAVORITE HEALTHY PEANUT BUTTER RECIPES

I like to try to incorporate peanut butter into as many things that I bake and cook as possible. Here’s the healthier stuff.

Peanut Butter Granola Clusters

1) Peanut Butter Chia Seed Granola – this (seriously) addictive granola has become a favorite among many of you too!

10.12granolabars

2) Easy and Healthy Homemade Granola Bars – lots of peanut butter, dates, honey, seeds, nuts and dried fruit go into these amazing bars!

3.20muffinsrack.jpg

3) Peanut Butter and Banana Muffins – Big, soft, fluffy muffins with just the right balance of peanut butter and banana flavor. They come in at under 200 calories per muffin.

3 FAVORITE PEANUT BUTTER DESSERT RECIPES

And here are my slightly more indulgent selections.

11.10cookies

1) Flourless Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies – just five ingredients and gluten-free. Warning: you can’t eat just one.

peanut-butter-chocolate-chip-bars

2) Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Bars – Fun story. Back in the early days I used to bake these bars and send them off to readers as a giveaway prize. 🙂 They are one of my favorite dessert recipes of all-time and have become a favorite of so many friends as well.

2.20cookies2

3) Peanut Butter Chocolate Chunk Cookies – these are great cookies to package up and give as gifts. They’re big and fluffy but still soft and chewy in the middle. They’re pretty sturdy and hold up well for transport.

ALL-TIME FAVORITE SAVORY PEANUT BUTTER RECIPE

Like I said, I like to find a way to include peanut butter into as many things as possible so I made a killer pad thai sauce with it!

Homemade Pad Thai

Homemade Pad Thai – I love that this recipe has made homemade Thai food accessible for so many of you for the first time! The sauce is easy and addictive. This is probably one of my most Pinned recipes ever!

Your turn!

I’d love to hear your peanut butter favorites! Share any of the categories above…favorite plain PB, favorite flavored, favorite healthy recipe, favorite PB dessert or favorite savory use of PB! 

{ 18 comments }

Recent Posts…

Three Days in Scottsdale + Climbing Camelback Mountain

Three Days in Scottsdale + Climbing Camelback Mountain

It’s hard to believe that it’s been almost a month since I ran the Every Woman’s Marathon! One of the fun things about this year’s race was getting to visit Scottsdale, Arizona. It was my first time in Arizona and while it was a quick trip, I tried to maximize my time there. Here’s a [...]

{ 3 comments }
Your Last-Minute Gift Guide For Everyone

Your Last-Minute Gift Guide For Everyone

In keeping with tradition, I’m coming in hot with a last-minute gift guide. As much as I’d like to think that one day I’ll be the kind of person who has their holiday shopping done before Black Friday…it’s just not a likely scenario. And I’m okay with that! I hope this list helps you finish [...]

{ 3 comments }
Gingerbread Banana Bread

Gingerbread Banana Bread

It’s holiday baking season and I’ve got a delicious new recipe to share with you – Gingerbread Banana Bread! This loaf is a mash up of gingerbread and banana bread and I’m here to tell you that these two are a match made in heaven! GINGERBREAD BANANA BREAD  If a baked good could be “warm [...]

{ 3 comments }
Thankful in Florida

Thankful in Florida

I am settled in back at home after a very special Thanksgiving in Florida. I cherish all of our trips to Florida but this one was extra meaningful because we had a bigger holiday crew this year. My cousin’s family came down and it was just the best to have a big tableful of people [...]

{ 2 comments }
2025 Advent Calendars for Everyone

2025 Advent Calendars for Everyone

Advent calendars have become such a fun tradition for us during the holiday season. Finn really looks forward to his daily surprise and I love the huge array of calendars to choose from – for kids and adults! I let Finn pick out his advent calendar this year and I think I might treat myself [...]

{ 0 comments }
Every Woman’s Marathon Scottsdale Recap (marathon #4!!!)

Every Woman’s Marathon Scottsdale Recap (marathon #4!!!)

I am on a three-hour flight home from Scottsdale so it seems like the perfect time to relive and recap yesterday’s Every Woman’s Marathon experience. I had a great day and I’m very proud of the race that I ran. It was a practice in “fun running” and that not every race effort has to [...]

{ 4 comments }
Hello from Scottsdale! (+ all the marathon anxiety)

Hello from Scottsdale! (+ all the marathon anxiety)

Hello from Scottsdale, Arizona where I am hydrating like crazy (especially in this dry desert air) and deep into a three day carb load in preparation for the Every Woman’s Marathon tomorrow! I’m going to get really real right away. I wish I could say that I was feeling excited and confident about the race but [...]

{ 1 comment }