subscribe to receive my posts, special offers, recipes, and workouts.
โ‰ก Menu

Tried and True Favorite Thanksgiving Recipes

18 of my Tried and True Favorite Thanksgiving Recipes

Thanksgiving is just a week away and if you’re finalizing your menu plan or deciding what you’ll be contributing to a family or group meal, this is the post for you. It’s not secret that I love to cook and Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday of the year. Over the last 10 years or so, I’ve handled every part of Thanksgiving at some point from creating the dinner menu and assigning tasks to baking rolls to contributing side dishes to providing the sweet stuff to brining and roasting the bird.

Tried and True Favorite Thanksgiving Recipes

In this post I’m going to share a compilation of my favorite tried and true Thanksgiving recipes. Some you can find on my blog and others are outside recipes that I’ve relied on for years. Hope you’re hungry…here we go! ๐Ÿ™‚

Appetizers

Relish Tray

(source)

I don’t know about you but Thanksgiving is one holiday where I prefer to bypass apps and snacking to save room for the main feast. That said, a friend introduced me to relish trays during a friendsgiving back in 2007 and it’s been my go-to ever since. They’re fun to put together, aesthetically pleasing, light and versatile.

The Modern Relish Tray
How to Build a Relish Tray
Thanksgiving Inspiration: The Modern Relish Tra

The Main Event

Alton Brown Good Eats Roast Turkey

First things first, BRINE YOUR BIRD! I swear it makes the biggest difference. I cooked this turkey two years ago and brined overnight in a huge bucket from Home Depot. This is the full recipe that I swear by when it comes to cooking the bird, from brining through roasting. It’s the Good Eats Roast Turkey from Alton Brown.

Turkey on the Big Green Egg

And if the Big Green Egg is your thing, I highly, highly, highly recommend my dad’s take on Alton’s recipe for the Big Green Egg. You can find it on my old blog!

Stuffed Pork Loin

If you want to mix it up this year and steer away from the traditional turkey or add another option, consider my cider-brined pork loin stuffed with butternut squash, apples and cranberries.

Stuffed Acorn Squash

And if you want to go meatless, my stuffed acorn squash with brown rice, kale, cranberries and pecans is where it’s at.

Sides

The Best Sweet Potato Casserole

I am obsessed with this sweet potato recipe from Southern Living and have been making it since 2007! I love the alternating rows of marshmallows and cornflake topping…it’s a crowd pleaser and tastes amazing!

Traditional White Dressing

My dad and I have been making this classic white dressing from Cuisine at Home forever and ever. Nothing fancy here, just your basic white dressing but this recipe is delicious!

Goumet Cookbook Mac and Cheese

I discovered this macaroni and cheese recipe in the Gourmet Cookbook back in 2009 when I was doing a 68 Days of Gourmet Challenge on my old food blog back in 2009. It remains my go-to mac and cheese recipe to this day.

Orange Ginger Cranberry Sauce

Orange ginger cranberry sauce. I love the addition of crystallized ginger along with orange juice and zest in this cranberry sauce recipe.

Thanksgiving Plate

My dad taught me to make homemade gravy from scratch and for that I am thankful. It’s a bit of a process but worth it 100%. I don’t have the recipe on my site or a link to it online but I made a pdf of the recipe my dad emailed me back in 2008 just for you guys! ๐Ÿ™‚ Click here.

Other delicious side dishes to check out…

Creamed Leeks
Shredded Brussels Sprouts with Caramelized Shallots
Tuscan Kale Salad with Golden Beets, Figs and Feta
Kale Salad with Butternut Squash, Pomegranate and Pumpkin Seeds
Fluffy Dinner Rolls
Green Beans with Caramelized Onions and Almond

Desserts

Bourbon Pumpkin Cheesecake

You can never go wrong with this Bourbon Pumpkin Cheesecake. I make it almost every year!

Maple Apple Spice Cake

This Maple Apple Spice Bundt Cake is so yummy.

Apple Cranberry Pie

My dad makes this gorgeous Apple Cranberry Pie from Cook’s Illustrated almost every year.

I could keep going all night long but I think this covers my absolute favorites.

Do you have any tried and true Thanksgiving recipes?

Favorite way to cook the bird? Smoke? Roast? Grill? Fry?

Favorite Thanksgiving dessert?

Save

{ 9 comments }

Recent Posts…

Life Lately: Summer So Far

Life Lately: Summer So Far

I want to bottle up this summer and make it last forever (well, maybe minus the wildly hot and humid weather that makes running a big thumbs down). I mentioned this in my last post…but I am really enjoying the slower pace and the days that feel like they have more space. While I’m trying [...]

{ 6 comments }
So Many Dinner Ideas

So Many Dinner Ideas

Happy Friday! I hope this post finds you well and enjoying the summer. We are in the dog days of it over here in Charlotte – the heat and humidity is off the charts – but it’s something I’ll embrace because I deeply appreciate the massive slow down that summer has brought. A lot of [...]

{ 4 comments }
Big Bear Peaks + Pines Race Recap (3-Day Stage Race, My First 50k)

Big Bear Peaks + Pines Race Recap (3-Day Stage Race, My First 50k)

I recently traveled to Big Bear Lake, California for the inaugural Big Bear Peaks + Pines three-day stage race hosted by TransRockies Running. This was my third TransRockies event in 12 months (see also Colorado + Moab) and I’m here to tell you that they can do no wrong when it comes to race organization [...]

{ 4 comments }
Reading, Watching, Listening (Spring 2026 Edition)

Reading, Watching, Listening (Spring 2026 Edition)

Happy weekend! Another week in the books! I got three runs in (6.5 miles, 5.5 miles, 5.5 miles) and I have a trail run planned for tomorrow. Total weekly mileage will end up around 30-35 miles depending on if I go for 13 or 17 tomorrow! I’m 16 weeks out from the Golden Ultra so [...]

{ 7 comments }
Life Lately: 8 Years Old, A New Piercing, Trail Training and More

Life Lately: 8 Years Old, A New Piercing, Trail Training and More

Happy Memorial Day Weekend. It’s a very rainy one here in Charlotte and while I am a little bummed not to be spending the weekend in Florida with the fam or by the pool at our swim club (just opened for the season!), I’m also welcoming a slower pace and time at home. It’s been [...]

{ 2 comments }
24 Things I’ve Made for Lunch Recently

24 Things I’ve Made for Lunch Recently

Hi and happy May! As we roll into the first full week of a new month, I have almost a month’s worth of lunch ideas for you. It’s a great mix of sandwiches, bowls, salads and wraps. I hope you enjoy and find some inspiration for your midday meal! Open-faced chickpea salad sandwich on toasted [...]

{ 4 comments }
Charlotte Racefest Half Marathon (Race Recap + First Time Pacing + Update On My Hip)

Charlotte Racefest Half Marathon (Race Recap + First Time Pacing + Update On My Hip)

I ran the Charlotte Racefest Half Marathon on April 18 to pace a longtime client and friend in her first half marathon and had the best day out there! 2026 CHARLOTTE RACEFEST HALF MARATHON This was half marathon number 12 for me and a really fun, enjoyable and rewarding one! I started training my friend [...]

{ 1 comment }